Church's future secure after holiday let plans approved

The future of a Grade II-listed church in Chapel-en-le-Frith has been secured after High Peak Council approved plans for a three-bedroom holiday let on the site.

Town End Methodist Church has received permission to convert a rear portion of the building into self-catering apartment, which they hope will bring in revenue and ensure the church remains open for worshippers and community events. 

As part of HPBC’s planning requirements, the renovation work must begin within three years, as well as keeping and painting the existing external doors. 

When finished, the let will have three bedrooms, a living room, kitchen, bathroom and a wet room.  

The proposals have received broad support from locals, with 22 letters in support of the scheme, including one from the church’s former Reverend Keith Sandow, who was unequivocal in his assessment. 

“Town End Methodist Church will close without this project. The building and its people have served the community for 150 years and want to continue to work alongside the community in the future.  

“We are one of very few public amenities that can accommodate large groups, so it is important that planning is granted. Further, the holiday accommodation seeks to make the downstairs assessable for people with mobility issues.” 

However, one person submitted a letter of concern at the public consultation stage. 

Peter Lawrence, who lives opposite the church said: "I do not want to have increased traffic directly outside my property, with church and school traffic we already have numerous issues over parking and damage to residents' vehicles and properties.  

“Nothing against people visiting the area coming from outside of town, but having constant visitors with no ties to the town or regard for the area, staying opposite my house is not something I wish for. 

“I bought the property for its quiet location, low crime and being next to a church, not next to a holiday let.” 

A HPBC conservation officer also sounded notes of caution. 

“The proposals would fail to preserve or enhance the character and appearance of the Conservation Area, contrary to Section 72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990.  

“With regards to the NPPF (2023) the harm would be less than substantial. With lack of detail and clear and convincing justification for this harm, the scheme cannot be supported.  

“At this time, it is not considered there are clear public benefits to outweigh the heritage harm identified. I cannot provide full support and recommend refusal.” 

However, the proposal passed despite these objections, with the committee citing a similar successful project at nearby Fernilee Methodist Church and the added tourism income it expects the scheme to bring. 

Made from local gritstone, the church also features a square tower with an unusual octagonal spire on top.